Patton and rommel. Patton Versus Rommel 2019-01-09

Patton and rommel Rating: 6,7/10 839 reviews

Patton and Rommel: Men of War in the Twentieth Century (Book Review)

patton and rommel

It gave many details about when and where they were born and contrasted them by going back and forth between the life of Patton and the life of Rommel. Patton and Rommel is the first single-volume study to deal with the parallel lives of two generals who earned not only the loyalty and admiration of their own men, but the respect of their enemies, and the enmity of the leaders they swore to obey. Eisenhower, who gave Patton's petrol supplies to the more cautious British General Bernard Montgomery. There are, however, more than a few spelling and minor factual errors. Whether climbing the Alps and the Carpathians, crossing the Meuse or driving like mad across the desert, Rommel gets the full treatment here. There are many fine scholars out there, professors who do their time in the archives, read the appropriate foreign languages and can fashion their material into a coherent argument. In this way an Allied player can roll up a major element of the German line and achieve a victory.

Next

Patton and Rommel by Dennis Showalter

patton and rommel

It is a good story, and the quality of the writing makes it even better. After the war he became a celebrated artist who enjoyed the patronage of Princess Grace of Monaco and the Duke and Duchess of Windsor. The game was very well received by war game enthusiasts but never became popular in a wider marketplace. He said, 'That guy is going to screw things up. Overall, I can't recommend this history to the serious student of military history.

Next

Patton and Rommel

patton and rommel

Several times during the war, Eisenhower had made decisions that in Patton's opinion prolonged the war and cost American lives. In the face of shattered communications, tremendous losses, constant retreating, and practically no air support, the enemy still maintained overall control of his tactical situation. Running low on tanks, ammunition and fuel, Rommel prepared to retreat. A month before, he could have entered Prague, but was also detained by Eisenhower, leaving him nailed to the ground by an order. Wrath Of Achilles: Essays On Command In Battle. He was friends with Salvador Dali, who painted a portrait of Bazata as Don Quixote.

Next

Old War Movies: THE PARALLEL DEATH OF PATTON AND ROMMEL

patton and rommel

This is not a bad book if you realize what it really is: a nice light-reading history. He had fought with too many important people. If you've seen the movie Patton, you have a fair idea of Patton's story already. Rommel, many similar characteristics, both leading from the front, both detailed planners who demonstrated the ability to adapt to new circumstances on the fly, both smart aggressive charismatic leaders. They never raised his name in the context of worthy strategists. Later in May 1945 he attended several meetings and social affairs with top Red Army officers, and he evaluated them carefully.

Next

Old War Movies: THE PARALLEL DEATH OF PATTON AND ROMMEL

patton and rommel

These two generals were both very similar in ways. He fought with specialist troops — mountain infantry — in the highly mobile Caporetto and Carpathian campaigns in Italy and Romania, and even in that pre-panzer era, he showed how a small, highly mobile elite could achieve success out of all proportion to its numbers. Polish Prime Minister and Commander-in-Chief from 1939 to 1943, General Wladyslaw Sikorski and his successor, General Kazimierz Sosnkowski, worked ceaselessly to integrate the Polish Home Army and its operations into the overall Western and especially British military strategy. The book's overall quality is spoiled by two of my biggest complaints: not a single photograph and not a single map. Plus, the textual descriptions of key battles, like El Alamein, Tobruk, Kasserine Pass and the Allied invasion of Sicily are good but abbreviated. Thus the accident was set up, which was not by any means the first.

Next

Patton and Rommel : Men of War in the Twentieth Century by Dennis E. Showalter (2006, Paperback)

patton and rommel

Towards the 1930's, it morphed into one of the best propaganda tools by governments to sway and instill ideas to its citizens. Gay and the driver Woodring were unharmed. Army top brass, a book has alleged. Eisenhower was the big surprise for me. Despite his profane, posturing manner, and the sheer enthusiasm for conflict that made both his peers and the public uncomfortable, Patton's very presence commanded respect. Army armor officer, examines in this deeply researched and finely crafted volume, the combat effectiveness of German heavy tank battalions. Their temperaments, both on and off the battlefield, were overwhelmingly contrary--but their approach to modern warfare was remarkably similar.


Next

Patton and Rommel: Men of War in the Twentieth Century (Book Review)

patton and rommel

The truck's driver and his passengers mysteriously disappeared -- as did the sergeant in a jeep who was leading the Patton Cadillac. The author has a very approachable writing style and he has a solid grasp on his subject matter. Both men were unique and had strong personalties and favored what were considered unorthodox ways. But one reason Patton was lucky was due to his meticulous planning; another was his intuition. Military history without even simple diagrams? There are loads of typos. The opinions expressed on this website are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Hoover Institution or Stanford University.

Next

Buy Patton And Rommel

patton and rommel

Books on World War 2 tend to end their accounts shortly after the end of the war, naturally. In November 1917, he was assigned to establish the First Army Tank School. Instead, it looks at the personalities and p There are mixed reviews about this book and I can see why that may be. He managed to cross the Seine, the Moselle, the Rhine, the Loire, the Saar, the Danube and many other rivers. Help Advance Ideas Defining a Free Society Become engaged in a community that shares an interest in the mission of the Hoover Institution to advance policy ideas that promote economic opportunity and prosperity, while securing and safeguarding peace for America and all mankind.

Next

Patton Versus Rommel

patton and rommel

It's well-known what extremely violent debates they had about how the civilian population of Germany was to be treated. Patton was a Calvary man who did not get into much action and Rommel was a forward Infantry Commander that fought on the front lines. His conduct of battle was as decisive as it was imaginative. Today, the evidence that he was murdered -- the first in a line of postwar political assassinations including that of President John F. Through the Eyes of His Enemies. There are plenty to go around, but either the author or the publisher, or, perhaps, both, dropped the ball, and left them out altogether.

Next

Patton and Rommel: Men of War in the 20'th Century

patton and rommel

They quickly overran front-line infantry and artillery positions. The research is thorough, the quality of the writing superb…Showalter ranks as a scholar who has done them justice, making two complex men and a vast panorama of military history remarkably accessible for experts and lay readers alike. I find it disconcerting since as a student of history and not a researcher I am unable to find many of the primary sources and must rely on others to provide them. I know who killed him. The game's , however, worked to be true to the strategies of each of the two generals.

Next